Response to Tim Bray.

In a recent weblog entry, Tim Bray wrote about some things he thought Ruby lacked. Since he doesn't have comments enabled, I thought I would share my opinions here, as a series of disjointed thoughts.

He said "Ruby needs an IDE. All programming languages need IDEs." Well, I completely agree with that, and for my serious Python programming (as opposed to noodling around in Python), I tend to use Eclipse, because it's there. Perhaps Ruby could take the same approach...

Of course, he also said a couple of things where I think he's a little off the mark. For instance "I should never have to scroll much; IDEs go to a lot of trouble to make it trivial to jump from wherever to the source for the method being called, or its docs, or the next compile error or breakpoint, or variable declaration, or whatever. Scrolling back and forth in a source-code file is just stupid." This I see more as a problem with his choice of editor, or perhaps his knowledge of its features. I'm fairly sure both emacs and vi allow you to jump to the things he's asking for...

"certain aspects of Unicode are, on the surface at least, objectively racist; for example, why does UTF-8 encoding of characters become progressively less efficient as you move from the languages of the Western hemisphere to those of the East?" Hmm... I don't know... My first guess would be because Western languages have approximately a 10,000th the number of characters as Eastern languages. My second guess would have something to do with Huffman coding and the prevalence of Western Language (mainly English) documents on the net, but I do recognize that this could be due to my only being able to read English.

As for Integration, isn't that what Parrot, .NET, and the JVM are supposed to provide us? If I'm wrong, and the language level is the appropriate level to solve this problem, then I sincerely hope that it's the Ruby and Python communities who get together to do something.

And finally, he missed what I consider to be the most important part of an IDE. (No, not Source Control Integration!) An integrated debugger. I had to go back to print statements to figure out what was happening in Demokritos recently, and it just sucked. So I added in some pdb support, and while it was easy to add the breakpoints, using it also sucked. Can we please show me the list of variables in a box at the top of my screen, and more than zero lines of context around the currently executing line? Please? It was so bad that I'm actually going to install Eclipse on my Mac Mini, just to avoid it in the future.

Comments

Comments powered by Disqus